Weed control without weedkiller: mulch, hoeing and timing
Weeds are easiest to beat while they are small and before they set seed. Most of the work is prevention: keep soil covered, avoid bringing buried seeds to the surface, and remove weeds early and regularly. A few minutes a week beats a full day each month.
Know what you are dealing with
| Type | Examples | How to control |
|---|---|---|
| Annual weeds | Crabgrass, chickweed, purslane, lambsquarters, hairy bittercress | Stop them setting seed: hoe or pull while small, mulch |
| Biennial weeds | Burdock, wild carrot, some thistles | Dig out the root in the first year, before they flower |
| Perennial weeds | Dandelion, bindweed, quackgrass, Canada thistle, ground ivy | Remove the whole root or keep cutting the top until the root runs out of reserves |
Annuals spread by seed, so one plant left to flower can seed a bed for years. Many perennials regrow from small pieces of root, so tilling them chops one plant into many.
Mulch
A 2 to 3 inch (5 to 8 cm) layer of organic mulch blocks light from weed seeds at the surface, and the few that sprout pull out easily. Lay it on weeded, moist soil. See how to mulch for depths and which mulch to use, and the mulch calculator for how much to buy. To clear lawn or a weedy patch for a new bed, sheet mulch with cardboard under the mulch.
Hoe and pull at the right time
- Hoe on a dry, sunny day, when cut weeds wither on the surface. Slice just below the soil surface with a sharp hoe; a stirrup or scuffle hoe cuts on both the push and pull. Do not dig deep, which brings up more seeds.
- Pull after rain, when moist soil releases the roots. Grip low at the base and pull steadily.
- Use a weeding fork or dandelion weeder for taproots, getting as much root out as you can.
- Weed weekly in the growing season. Seedlings take seconds to remove; established weeds take minutes.
- Never let weeds flower. If you cannot remove them, at least cut off flower heads before they set seed.
Wear gloves, especially for thistles and nettles, and know poison ivy (three leaflets per leaf, often glossy, as a vine or shrub). Do not pull it barehanded, wash tools and gloves afterwards, and never burn it, since the smoke carries the irritant oil.
Disturb the soil less
Soil holds a bank of weed seeds that sprout when brought to the light. Digging and tilling bring up a new crop each time. Once beds are established, add compost on top rather than digging it in.
The stale seedbed
Before sowing slow crops such as carrots, prepare the bed, water it, and wait a week or two for the first flush of weeds to sprout. Hoe them off very shallowly, without turning the soil, then sow. Fewer weeds come up with the crop.
Smother or solarize larger areas
- Smothering (occultation): cover the area with an opaque tarp or heavy black plastic, weighted at the edges, for several weeks in the growing season. Weeds and their seedlings die in the dark.
- Solarization: in the hottest part of summer, water the soil well and cover it with clear plastic, sealed at the edges, for 4 to 6 weeks. The trapped heat kills many weed seeds and seedlings near the surface. It works best in full sun and hot climates.
Neither reliably kills deep-rooted perennials such as bindweed, which need repeated removal over a season or more.
Weeds in lawns
A thick lawn mowed high is the best defense, because the grass shades out weed seedlings. Dig out dandelions and other broadleaf weeds with a weeding tool, and overseed thin patches. See lawn care basics.
Patios, paths and driveways
- Scrape out weeds in joints with a paving knife or a narrow weeding tool, and sweep with a stiff brush regularly so seeds do not lodge.
- Refill cleaned joints with jointing sand or polymeric sand, following the product directions, so there is less space for seeds to root.
- String trimmers can cut weeds along edges. Wear eye and hearing protection, closed shoes and long trousers, keep children and pets away, and switch off and disconnect power (or remove the battery) before clearing the line head.
If you use a weedkiller
The label is the law. In the US, using any herbicide in a way inconsistent with its label violates federal law. Use it only on the sites and weeds the label lists, at the label rate, with the protective equipment it states, and keep children and pets away for as long as it says. Spray only on still days so it does not drift onto garden plants, and keep it well away from vegetables unless the label allows that use. Keep it in its original container, out of reach, and never pour it into a drink bottle.
- Kitchen vinegar is not a labeled weedkiller. Horticultural vinegar (about 20 percent acetic acid or more) is sold as a herbicide, and at that strength it can severely burn skin and eyes. Use only a product with an EPA registration number on the label, with eye protection and gloves. It burns the leaves it touches but often does not kill perennial roots.
- Do not use salt, borax, bleach or homemade weedkiller mixtures. They are not tested or registered, and salt and borax can leave soil unable to grow plants for years.